David
Mamet’s 1984 Pulitzer-Prize-winning play, Glengarry
Glen Ross, is about the struggles of four shady small-time salesmen in a
small branch of a larger real estate company located in
The author, Mamet, had worked for a year
in a
Mamet shows how hucksters use language
to con customers and each other. He employs sporadic conversations and erratic
speech patterns to convey their thoughts and personalities. Mamet illustrates that
language is a con man’s tool and that conversation can be used to persuade, convince,
and lie. His characters use language and storytelling in order to survive in
their dismal and dreary situations and to exalt that survival. Mamet’s
characters define themselves through their language and discourse. Each
character’s ability or inability to sell is essential to his identity and
relationships to the others.
The original play is set in two
locations—a rundown Chinese restaurant across the street from the shabby real
estate office, and the dingy office itself. The appearance of both the
restaurant and the office sets us up for the darkness, gloom, and sense of
despair of the salesmen themselves. The three scenes of Act I take place in the
restaurant, and Act II entirely takes place the following day in the office.
The film version is fairly true to the play with two scenes added. One scene
shows one of the salesmen making an unsuccessful sales call at someone’s home.
The other scene effectively adds a new character who threatens the salesmen at
the beginning of the screenplay version. Blake (played by Alec Baldwin), a
slick troubleshooter from downtown, is sent to shake up the salesmen.
The very first scene of the film version
is valuable by making explicit much of what is subsequently illustrated,
explained, or implied in the succeeding events of the play. The film begins
with an emergency meeting in the shabby real estate office. Blake, a tough
emissary sent by downtown bosses Mitch and Murray, delivers a “pep talk” to the
salesmen. He tells the salesmen that they are all fired and that the only way
to get their jobs back is to close enough deals in the sales contest he is
instituting. Blake is arrogant, pompous, and takes pleasure in demeaning the
salesmen. He delivers his talk in unprofessional, negative, and vulgar
language. He cracks the whip by pitting the salesmen against each other in a
sales contest. They will be fired unless they get “on the board.” There is an
ever-present chalkboard in the front of the office that consistently reminds
them of the contest at all times—it is literally in their faces.
Blake informs them that the winner will
get a Cadillac, the second place finisher will receive a set of steak knives,
and the rest of them will be fired. He says that each of them will be given two
leads by Williamson, the office manager, and that they had until the next
morning to turn them into sales. The salesmen know that the leads are old and
worthless and two of them, Dave Moss and Shelly Levene complain that they are
old leads. Blake’s attempts to “teach” the salesmen how to sell merely amount
to repeating two acronyms—ABC (Always Be Closing) and AIDA (Attention,
Interest, Decision, and Action).
The first scene in Act I of the play
shows Shelly “the Machine” Levene attempting to persuade John Williamson, the
sales manager, to give him some of the premium leads locked up in the office.
Williamson has 500 good Glengarry leads that are only to be distributed to “closers.” The
desperate and despairing Levene pleads, brags, flatters, bullies, and attempts
to bribe the office manager in order to obtain the leads. Levene tries to bribe
Williamson by offering him fifty dollars for every lead plus 20 percent of the
profit made. The unsympathetic, heartless, and impassive office manager says he
wants his money up front.
Levene, a great salesman in the past,
needs money to pay for his sick daughter’s medical bills. As a tragic figure who
boasts about his past accomplishments, Levene brings to mind the character Willy
Loman in Arthur Miller’s 1949 play Death
of a Salesman. Viewed by Williamson as expendable, Shelly, the worn-out
sagging old timer, has been on a losing streak not having made a sale in
months. Levene attributes his misfortunes on the economy and the lack of
quality leads that Williamson gives him. He views Williamson as a naïve,
incompetent, sadistic, and bureaucratic young man with no sales experience.
Williamson takes orders from Mitch and
Murray, the downtown sales bosses. The uncharismatic and ruthless sales manager
resorts to fear and intimidation and is not respected by the salesmen. They
despise both Williamson and the system under which they work. Lacking in
leadership skills, the spineless Williamson is a stooge for the main office
downtown who has never had to live by his wits as a salesman on the front line.
In scene two of Act I, Dave Moss and
George Aaronsow are at the Chinese restaurant engaging in a conversation about
the unfairness of the distribution of the leads. They are offended by the
company’s disrespect for its employees. In order to get the good leads one had
to make sales and in order to make sales one needed to have the good leads. The
angry and ruthless Moss shares his idea of stealing the leads and selling them
to a former colleague and current competitor, Jerry Graff, who is in business
for himself. The bitter, intimidating, and aggressive Moss wants the timid,
reserved, and soft-spoken Aaronsow to break into the office and steal the
leads. Moss informs Aaronsow that even if he did not participate in the robbery
he would still be an accessory before the fact because he had talked to Moss
about the robbery plot—for the salesmen it appears that talking implies action.
He tells Aaronsow that if he breaks in himself he will name Aaronsow as an
accomplice.
Ricky Roma, the star of the sales force,
is also at the Chinese restaurant. Roma is a subtle, smooth, instinctual, and
informal salesman who does not need a list of hot prospects to make sales—for
him every person is a potential customer—even bar strangers. Roma is able to
improvise according to his sense of each occasion. He works magic on potential
customers by avoiding the hard sell and by getting the potential clients to
trust him. Roma has the knack of persuading customers to purchase what they
neither need nor want. He knows how to use language (often vulgar) to sell his
point. He expertly employs language to engage prospective buyers in small talk,
thereby placing them at ease. The charming Roma thinks out of the box and uses
his finesse to manipulate his target. Roma’s sales acumen embodies the art of
selling. He knows how to get the potential customer to trust him. Of course, he
does not really care about the customer but he has the ability to make the
customer believe that he cares.
At the bar in the Chinese restaurant,
Roma spots James Lingk and identifies him as a great target. Observing Roma in
action permits us to experience vicariously the salesman’s thrill of the chase.
He shows us how talk can transfer needs from the salesman to the potential
customer and power from the potential customer to the salesman. Realizing that
Lingk does not believe he enjoys or is in control of his life, Roma engages in
a philosophical monologue in which he talks about the meaning of life, risk-taking,
and seizing the moment. Roma plays to Lingk’s insecurities.
Approaching Lingk as a friend, Roma
talks about opportunities and questions the idea of morality. Creating a
comfortable setting for Lingk, Ricky uses vulgar language to proclaim the absence
of absolute morality in the world and the responsibility of each person to be
the master of his own fate. Roma never stops talking, suggests outrageous and
extravagant opportunities, and gets Lingk to actually believe that he is his
own man. The ace huckster gets Lingk to buy land that he can’t afford. Roma
does not even consider if he is doing anything wrong—he just does his job the
best way that he knows how to do it.
Act II takes place the following morning
at the shabby real estate office which consists of four desks, a coffee pot,
the chalkboard, and a couple of windows. The office is disheveled and the
leads, telephones, and some contracts had been stolen.
Williamson and Aaronsow are in the outer
office and Moss is being interrogated by a police detective named Baylen. When
they arrive, both Roma and Levene believe that they have closed deals from the
night before but their deals have not really been closed. Moss emerges from the
inner office and is outraged by the way that the detective has treated him. The
hot-headed Moss hears Levene raving about his successful deal and storms out.
Moss’s anger appears to be a charade to make him look to be uninvolved in the
office break-in.
Shelly is heartened by his successful sale.
When he enters the office he thinks that he is the new leader in the
competition. Levene boasts about the $80,000 plus sale he made the previous
night to Bruce and Harriett Nyborg. The self-secure Ricky Roma congratulates
the sagging old-timer on the sale. When he hears about the robbery, Ricky is
concerned about whether or not his deal from the night before has been
processed.
James Lingk enters the office to renege
on the deal he made with Roma. His wife does not approve of it. Knowing that he
has three business days to change his mind, he wants to make certain that the
contract has not yet been filed and that his check has not been cashed. Roma
informs Lingk that neither event has occurred and that there is plenty of time
to back out of the deal if he really wants to do so. Roma suggests that he and
Lingk meet on Monday to discuss the situation knowing that by then it will be
too late to cancel the deal.
Roma teams up with Levene to make it
appear that Roma has an important satisfied client, a senior vice-president of
American Express, who has bought property from Roma and who has to be rushed
immediately to the airport. Roma and Levene improvise to mislead and manipulate
the tearful, pathetic customer who came to the office to demand a refund. Ricky
admires Shelly for his spontaneous ability to cleverly play their con game. He
only had to give Levene a few cues regarding how to proceed.
Williamson emerges from his office to
ruin Roma and Levene’s team effort. The inexperienced office manager misreads
the situation. He mistakenly thinks that Lingh is upset by the disorder of the
office and reassures Lingh that the deal has gone through despite the robbery
and that the contract has been processed and the check has been deposited the
night before. At that point, Lingk realizes that he is being scammed. He leaves
upset proclaiming that he is going to report Roma to the Attorney General.
Roma blows up and is furious with
Williamson for sabotaging the deal. Levene joins Roma in berating and vilifying
the office manager. After Roma goes in for questioning by Officer Baylen,
Levene gets himself into serious trouble by telling Williamson that he should
not have lied about having processed the deal and having cashed the check.
Everyone knows that it was the office manager’s policy to nightly take the
checks to the bank and to file the contracts. As luck would have it, the
previous night Williamson failed to do so. The only way Shelly could have known
that was if he had been in the office the night before. Williamson is thereby
tipped off that Levene was the guilty party who had robbed the office.
The office manager knows that Levene is
guilty. Levene attempts to deny the crime but eventually folds, admits his
guilt (and that of Moss), begs for mercy, and attempts to bribe Williamson. He
admits to selling the leads to Graff. To add to Levene’s woes, Williamson tells
Levine that the Nyborg’s check is no good and that they are a crazy old couple
who simply like to talk to salesmen. He had purposely given Shelly the worst
possible leads. Levene asks Williamson why he is reporting him to the police
and the office manager responds, “Because I don’t like you.” Levene had begun
the day with pride believing that he had made a major sale but he certainly did
not end the day that way.
Roma exits the interrogation, praises
Levene, and attempts to convince Levene into being his partner so that he can
share in the commission. Williamson has revealed Levene and Moss as the thieves
to the detective. Shelly goes in to confess to Baylen just as Ricky is telling
Levene how much he admires him. There is no closure at the end of the play. The
selling goes on as we observe Ricky heading back to the Chinese restaurant.
Mamet’s character-centered play portrays
a passionate, dismal, brutal world in which all of the characters are tragic
figures. One moment a salesman praises a colleague and the next moment he
betrays him. Teamwork is only evident among the salesmen when they conspire to
bamboozle a customer or to steal from the company. The salesmen attempt to sound
confident when they are on the phone but they are actually haunted by despair
and desperation. They talk to make a living and most of the time they try to
hide the truth. They appear to be addicted to what they do and exhibit the
desire to manipulate. The main purpose of their talking is to claim power over
others or to withhold power from them. They lie that they are in town for only
a few hours, that there are only a few lots left, and so on. Playing roles and
living by their wits seem to come naturally for these salesmen. We could say
that the characters themselves are, in fact, actors.
The reader might wonder if these
salesmen are naturally deceitful scam-artists who are attracted to their
profession or if their organizational climate requires them to act the way they
do. There is no loyalty or trust by or to the organization. The salesmen are
driven by the bosses to participate in a dog-eat-dog cutthroat competition.
Leadership, if any, is boss-centered and Theory X oriented. The salesmen are
not mentored. There is no goal clarification or participation and the employees
are in no way empowered. They fear punishment and the only motivation provided
is negation—the chance to keep their jobs. A leader should be able to motivate
his subordinates through the joint formulation of goals and the facilitation of
the attainment of their goals. The organization has no people-centered practices
or policies. There is no talk about providing value to the customers.
This play can be looked at as a
description of a new kind of American salesmanship, a detective story with a
surprise ending, and as a dogfight for power, domination, and survival. The
excellent film adaptation includes a fine ensemble cast: Ricky (Al Pacino),
Shelly (Jack Lemmon), Blake (Alec Baldwin), Dave (Ed Harris), George (Alan
Arkin), John (Kevin Spacey), and James (Jonathan Pryce).
The
Rational Argumentator